Popular Posts

Monday, November 14, 2011

Carbon taxes add value for smart businesses

      Do you think that global climate change is happening?
      If you think it is happening, do you think that people are causing it?
      Do you follow the news on emissions controls such as cap and trade or carbon tax schemes?
      Do you think the answers matter? Because I don’t. 
      Why? There’s no point squabbling about it – BECAUSE – carbon emissions are what we call a ‘proxy indicator’ of waste: they are one measurement that indirectly measures lots of other things. So if your vehicle fleet is poorly maintained, you’ll be wasting fuel and oil – that is, carbon – and a good fleet maintenance program will save you not only fuel but also wear and tear on your vehicles. Yes, that’s right – it will save you MONEY.
      It’s the same for any other form of waste. Everything we do or use has a carbon cost.
Those offcuts in your factory come from goods or materials that were grown, mined or caught, transported, processed, transported again, processed by you – then transported to the landfill. Reduce that waste, and you reduce the amount of carbon you emit whenever you waste goods or materials that you bought from your suppliers. What do you save? MONEY.
      Work in an office? Good insulation, more efficient lighting and heating, more energy-efficient equipment and a host of other straightforward measures will reduce the carbon emissions from running the building and providing your services. What do you save? MONEY.
      It works for everything from farming cows to cloud computing.
      See? Climate change is not the enemy – and carbon is your friend!
      It shows you where your use of resources of all kinds is needlessly costly, and how you can run a smarter, more cost-effective organization.
      It also means we can leave the science of the debate to the scientists. So, if climate change is happened and we are causing it, reducing our carbon emissions means we’ll have taken some big steps to slowing it down – thereby reducing some very serious (and expensive) risks to people and economies all round the world. If it isn’t happening or we aren’t causing it, our businesses will be more intelligent, efficient and profitable.  
      Either way, we win - IF we take action.


"What is the worst that could happen?" This is a wonderful book on the topic by Greg Craven. Click here and here to see him talk about that and "How It All Ends" – sensationally good and very funny. 

Tuesday, November 1, 2011

Heading past seven billion people on the planet - exploding some population myths

      The birth of numbers of symbolic 7-billionth babies round the world has been greeted with both happiness and horror. Joy of course to the parents, accompanied by worry about whether the planet can support its burgeoning population.
      Yet already by the 3rd Century, Tertullian was saying “We are burdensome to the world, the resources are scarcely adequate for us… already nature does not sustain us” - this at a time when world population was some 200 million. 18 centuries later and with 34 times more people, others including Thomas Malthus and Paul Ehrlich have predicted disasters arising from overpopulation.
      However as many observers including Jared Diamond and author and journalist Fred Pearce pointed out in the late 20th Century and early 2000s, the biggest threat is not too many people: it's the gross (and ultimately unsatisfying) over-consumption of resources by 20% of the world’s population which leaves depleted and polluted resources for the 80% of the world’s less privileged. In fact David Suzuki said in an interview that if we all lived like the average american, the world could only support 200 million people - maybe Tertullian was onto something!
      Compounding this result, we're seeing the number of households increase faster than the number of people: more and more single people or childless couples fill their homes with all the appliances and other things that can service whole families.
      In recent decades we've realised (largely by accident) that the best antidote to explosive population growth is female literacy: teach women to read and they will access the family planning they need – provided infant mortality is reduced. If parents know their children will survive to young adulthood, they will reduce their family size.
      Where this happens, the rapidity of the resulting demographic transition is startling: it inverts the classic population pyramid – lots of children at the base, a narrow peak of old people and a thin tier in between of income earners supporting them both – into a tower with wider cap of older people supported by a shrinking workforce to be succeeded in turn by an even smaller number of children. This is what we now see in Japan, Europe, Scandinavia and other "developed" economies.
      Commentators now believe that if higher living and educational standards spread round the world (before its economy and ecology are toppled by unsustainably high demands on water and other resources) the world’s population is likely to stabilize at about 9 billion people – and it is likely to fall as more and more people enjoy better lifestyles.
      And it seems that industrial-scale agriculture is not needed  over every square inch of the Earth - in developed nations we waste a quarter or a third of our food while in other parts of the world, war, pests and poor storage rob the people of the opportunities to farm their land and of the fruits of their labour when they do.
      So we need to focus on getting to a world full of healthy people whose ability to live happily is supported by stable states. 
      If course this would signal a major re-think of the current growth-based economic model, as we move towards stable or shrinking populations and while some of us on the planet learn how to live more happily by consuming less so as to enable those who need to consume more to enjoy a decent standard of living. 
      As Jared Diamond points out, "Real sacrifice wouldn’t be required ...because ... much American consumption is wasteful and contributes little or nothing to quality of life. For example, per capita oil consumption in Western Europe is about half of ours, yet Western Europe’s standard of living is higher by any reasonable criterion, including life expectancy, health, infant mortality, access to medical care, financial security after retirement, vacation time, quality of public schools and support for the arts. Ask yourself whether Americans’ [and of course, the rest of us in the developed world] wasteful use of gasoline contributes positively to any of those measures."
      There's hope! And enough happiness to go round.


See a wonderful short video on the numbers here.

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

An oil spill on iconic beaches: time for local capacity-building and shipping to go green

      My heart is wrung by the toxic bunker oil killing birds and sea life along the beach where I grew up: the magnificent Bay of Plenty on New Zealand's beautiful East Coast. My friends along the beaches at Mt Maunganui and Papamoa are distraught, and communities on Motiti and Mayor Islands and all along the Bay from the Mount to Maketu are horrified at the damage it will do to traditional, recreational and commercial fisheries, tourism and the hearts and minds of people who use these beaches every day, all year round.
      Search for "Rena, Astrolabe Reef" and you will see it all.  Many questions remain, notably why a ship should hit a well-charted reef in fine weather, and why it took nearly a week of said fine weather before the first signs of activity took place to prevent the spilling of the 1700 tonnes of oil on board. And why a ship that has had a number of deficiencies identified in New Zealand in September and been detained for in Australia for other deficiencies to be made good should have been allowed to continue plying New Zealand waters. The Captain and First Officer have been arrested and Maritime New Zealand has dramatically stepped up its on the ground response, its level of communication with the affected communities and its training of volunteers to help remove the ghastly globs and dead and dying birds now washing up on the beaches.
      More information will emerge over time, but this tragedy got me thinking about two of my passions: capacity-building and the low-carbon economy.
      As I understand it, local ports like Tauranga, where the Rena was headed, used to have their own spill response capability, but legislative changes some years ago centralised this function in Wellington, our capital city, which is more or less in the middle of New Zealand at the southern end of the North Island. It appears that at least some of the delay in response was a result of this physical distance - 460 nautical miles.
      Why not restore this function to the ports, with Maritime New Zealand taking a strategic analysis and training role? New Zealand has a small population, a tad over 4.4 million, but the length of our coastline gives us one of the world's biggest exclusive economic zones. This makes it hard for us to police the area, so why not re-establish local emergency response capacity in a way that shares roles and resourcing? Inspection, education and where necessary enforcement of cultural, recreational and commercial shell and fin fisheries could be one role; search and rescue another; alongside emergency response capacity. Complement this with outreach and training for the communities who are spontaneously taking on an active kaitiaki and guardianship role and you have a skilled and committed resource. There are already many iwi and marine, dune and beach care groups and many other environmental and community groups of all kinds along the Bay of Plenty and with the right kind of support, their capacity could be further built up in many areas.
      But why do we still have ships on the seas with such dangerous and outdated carbon-intense technology?
      Ports and their approaches all round the world are vulnerable to maritime mishaps. Yet it's possible to have ships with a mere modicum of lubricating oil on board that are powered by kite sails, solar panels and even solar panels on towers that can be turned to act as sails as well as energy-harvesters. These ships can cut a ship's fuel costs by up to 90% and significantly lower its environmental impact. Even better, they're beautiful - take a look here - reminiscent of the glory days of sailing ships! The solar cells can capture energy for storage, while the kites can be used in overcast weather to conserve battery charges. The batteries can then power electric engines for use in bad weather and maneuvering in and out of harbours and ports.
      Electric engines have powerful, energy-efficient variable speed drives. They are nearly silent - a tremendous boon to our marine life now suffering increasing levels of disruption and physical damage from ever-growing levels of human-induced noise. We'd have to think of new ways to warn at-risk animals of imminent collisions  - and this is a great opportunity for innovative research and technology that could be applied more widely, for example to underwater turbines and the like.
      Yes, batteries are toxic and dangerous things - but they don't escape and float away to kill life in the water and on our coastlines: if they go down with a ship, they are far more readily recoverable than fossil fuels.
      Oh, and this would help us on the way to a low-carbon economy - a report by the U.N. International Maritime Organisation said annual CO2 emissions from world shipping reached 1.12 billion tonnes in 2007, about 3.5% of total global carbon emissions, and that growing international seaborne trade and related fuel consumption will raise emissions from ships by 30 % to 1.475 billion tonnes by 2020.
      Which will be the first world port to insist on a sustainable supply chain by accepting only wind and solar-powered vessels?
      Hmmm.... how many pluses does all this add up to compared with one giant minus on the beach which I will visit to mourn over next weekend?
      And of course, the fly in the ointment of this particular panacea is.... oil tankers. Not much point having them electric when they carry millions of litres of oil as their cargo. As Greenpeace said in a 25 February 1990 advertisement in the New York Times (I've rephrased it slightly), "It wasn't the Exxon Valdez captain's driving that caused the Alaskan oil spill. It was ours."
      Now that's a whole new conversation!

Sunday, September 18, 2011

Learning to love learning

      Over the last few weeks I've been immersed in work on measuring the outcomes and effectiveness of watershed management plans - stuff I've been looking at for some years now. The most common finding is that many plans aren't written in a way that enables their implementation and outcomes to be documented. Among the many other barriers to identifying the effectiveness of our plans are lack of time for overworked staff to look back at their achievements and a widespread culture of fear in public and private spheres. People are scared of 'getting it wrong'.
      This is so sad. In both business and government I see people who love their work. Giving them the tools and time to step back and reflect on their organization and its operations is part of the process of developing a form of reflexive awareness, and is a major step on the path to becoming a learning organization that 'gets' continuous improvement. This sets alight a love of learning about our work by way of monitoring, review and adaptive management - something environmental agencies talk about a great deal but find harder to do in practice.
      How much time and money to invest in monitoring and evaluation varies between organizations and their function, but I've seen a figure of 5-10% of project budget suggested by Katie Delahaye Paine, and this gives us somewhere to start.
      We need a very strategic and holistic yet targeted approach, especially if we are aiming to assess outcomes and effectiveness across the four social, cultural economic and environmental wellbeings. Sometimes minor tweakings of approach can enable us to create benefits across two or more of these wellbeings and we need to track this thinking and doing.
      Einstein, it seems, was a genius in more than just physics: one of my favorite quotes from him is 'Everything that can be counted does not necessarily count; everything that counts cannot necessarily be counted.'